English 225

--Introduction to Film Paper Topics--

(Christopher Jacobs sections)

BRIEF WRITING ASSIGNMENTS

Students will receive one point each for 16 weekly “reaction papers” a half-page to one-page (200- to 400-word) in length, discussing the films shown in Tuesday’s class session. These should be turned in at the Wednesday or Thursday lecture-discussion session and must be turned in no later than the following week to receive full credit. The second or third week after the film, they may still be turned in for half-credit, but will not receive any credit if turned in later than that.

Other brief writing assignments may (or may not) be given at various times throughout the semester, such as reaction or analytical papers on special film showings outside of class, or a concise one- to two-page review of some film currently playing in theatres. Some may be collaborative efforts by several students (such as developing scenes for an unfinished screenplay) prepared in small groups divided up in class and turned in by one person from the group. Each of these short assignments will be worth about one to five points toward your final grade. Some may be required assignments and some may be assigned as optional extra credit. More details will be announced in class regarding these assignments.

 

SEMESTER PROJECT – Spring 2008

You have three possible options for your major project, worth 80 points toward your final grade:

--Either TWO 5-page ANALYTICAL PAPERS (paper #1 due February 26th  and paper #2 due April 15th)   

--or ONE 10-page RESEARCH PAPER due April 15th  IS REQUIRED *

--You may also choose to write, produce, and direct a movie instead of writing the paper(s).

Note that all papers are to be double-spaced with 1-inch to 1 ¼ -inch margins and 10 to 12-point type. See Guidelines for Writing Papers on line for more details. For these papers you will also need to locate and watch films outside of class, most likely by renting, borrowing, buying them on DVD or VHS, or possibly finding them on a cable movie channel like Turner Classic Movies. (Start looking for them NOW!) If you do a screenplay, you must use standard screenplay format, and if you want to produce it you will need to have access to video equipment including a camcorder and a computer with video editing software (see below for more details).


 

Main Writing Assignments

 

OPTION 1)  -- Two four- to five-page analytical papers (approx. 1500-words):
     Probably the easiest choice! Recommended for most students.

 

Paper #1 – (5 pages) - Worth 40 points – Due February 26th, 2008

-Write a Narrative Analysis of one or two films from the list below, employing one or more of the concepts of narrative film form discussed in Barsam’s Looking at Movies, Chapters 1 and 2 (or Bordwell & Thompson Chapter 3, if you have a copy of their Film Art).  If you choose two films, be sure to compare and contrast how each uses these narrative concepts in similar or different ways. If you choose only one film, you can explore your subject in greater depth and detail, perhaps preparing a plot segmentation outline to aid in your analysis. You might want to concentrate on the Plot/Story distinction, for example, or handling of narrative time, or on cause & effect, or a specific character’s function/development, but you are not limited to a single concept. Whatever elements of narrative you discuss, be as specific as you can in showing how those elements function in the particular film you choose to discuss (using examples from the film). You will want to try to explain why particular narrative elements are used in a particular way. You should consider the questions that Barsam poses in the “Analyzing Narrative” sidebar at the end of Chapter 2 of Looking at Movies to help formulate your own understanding of the film. It can help to watch the movie one or more additional times with its audio commentary, if the DVD has one (although some commentaries are more useful than others). Do NOT just write a synopsis and do NOT simply describe scenes from the film. Do NOT analyze the cinematography, editing, sound, or mise en scene for this paper. Instead, describe how the scenes and story material are organized into a coherent plot, perhaps explaining the function(s) that certain individual scenes or plot elements serve in the overall film (e.g., character development, foreshadowing, motivation for later events, etc.). Some films may lend themselves to analyzing their characters as the primary driving force of the plot, while others may be more concerned with actions, and others with themes and ideas. Throughout your discussion USE SPECIFIC EXAMPLES that illustrate your statements!!  If you do the two-film option for Paper #1, whether using remakes or two films with very similar plot elements, be sure to point out similarities and differences in attitude and approach, and other significant changes like additions, deletions, or reordering of material.

 

-You will need to see one or two of the following films—many are available at local video stores or at the Grand Forks Public Library but some may need to be special-ordered: 


 

TWO-FILM papers:  Casablanca PLUS To Have and Have Not,  Yojimbo PLUS A Fist Full of Dollars OR Last Man Standing,  Seven Samurai PLUS The Magnificent Seven, Pygmalion PLUS My Fair Lady,  Roxie Hart PLUS Chicago,  Anna and the King of Siam (1946) PLUS The King and I, Dracula (1931) PLUS The Mummy (1932), Wedding Present PLUS His Girl Friday, War of the Worlds (both 1953 and 2005 versions), King Kong (just the 1933 and 1976 versions), The Ten Commandments (both the 1923 and 1956 versions), Ben-Hur (both the 1925 and 1959 versions), King of Kings (both the 1927 and 1961 versions), The Front Page (just the 1931 and 1974 versions), The Maltese Falcon (just the 1931 and 1941 versions), The Big Sleep (either 1945 or ’46 and 1978 versions), The Racket (both 1928 and 1951 versions), The Picture Snatcher PLUS Ace in the Hole,   Cape Fear (both 1962 and 1991 versions), It’s a Wonderful Life PLUS Click, MacKenna's Gold PLUS The Mummy (1999 version), The Poseidon Adventure PLUS Poseidon, The Producers (both 1968 and 2005 versions), Crimes and Misdemeanors PLUS Match Point, Alexander the Great PLUS Alexander, The 300 Spartans PLUS 300

 

ONE-FILM papers: The Whispering Chorus, The Golden Chance, Male and Female, The Oyster Princess, The Blot, Doctor Mabuse The Gambler (1922 two-part version), The Man from Beyond, Three Ages, The Navigator (1924), The Iron Horse (1924), Safety Last, The Gold Rush (original 1925 cut), The Kid Brother, Steamboat Bill Jr., King of Kings (1927 version), Queen Kelly, Hangman’s House, The Man Who Laughs, Pandora’s Box, City Lights, Prix de Beauté, Scarface (1932 version), 42nd Street, It Happened One Night, Design for Living, The Sin of Nora Moran, Mayor of Hell, Four Frightened People, My Man Godfrey (1936 version), You Can’t Take It With You, Only Angels Have Wings, Black Legion, Union Pacific, Sullivan’s Travels, Double Indemnity, The Seventh Victim, Curse of the Cat People, The Philadelphia Story, Children of Paradise, The Road to Utopia, How Green Was My Valley, Meet John Doe, I See a Dark Stranger, Nightmare Alley, Ace in the Hole, On Dangerous Ground, His Kind of Woman, Kiss Me Deadly, Vertigo, Cinema Paradiso, Day for Night, 8½, Stardust Memories, The Seventh Seal, The Passenger, The Conformist, Reds, Bride of Frankenstein, The Old Dark House (1932 version), On the Waterfront, Wings of Desire, Wild Strawberries, L’Avventura, Alexandria Again and Forever, Man Bites Dog, More American Graffiti, Persona, Fanny and Alexander, The Tenant, The Iceman Cometh, Léon the Professional, Red Rock West, Eraserhead, She’s Gotta Have It, Wild at Heart, Audition, The Big Animal, Ravenous, The Smokers, Mulholland Drive, Lost Highway, The Ice Storm, A Beautiful Mind, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, De-Lovely, Little Miss Sunshine, Schultze Gets the Blues, Dangers from Within, Miss Mystic, Dark Highways, The Threat of the Mummy, Vengeance of the Sorceress, Hometown Assassins, Dick's Beer, Boundless, Looking for Lillian, Cold Harbor, Reign Over Me, Sweet Land, The Station Agent, Volver, Redbelt


 

Paper #2 – (5 pages) -  Worth 40 points – Due April 15th, 2008

-Write an essay exploring camerawork and editing in one brief (5 to 10-minute) continuous segment from one of the films listed below. Your analysis should consider some of the issues discussed in Barsam’s Looking at Movies chapter 4 (summarized in the “Analyzing Cinematography” sidebar on p. 192) and chapter 6 (summarized in the “Analyzing Editing” sidebar on p. 270).  You should consider how the segment functions both as a self-contained unit and within the film as a whole. It might be instructive to count the number of shots in your sequence and time how long each one is. To help you decide exactly what to write, you will want to ask yourself some questions:  Does the camera remain stationary or does it move through the setting (and if so, how and why?), or does it do both at different times? Where is the camera positioned in the scene, how does it frame the actors and props, and how does the choice of lens affect the way they appear? How long is each take? Does the average shot length change at different parts of the scene, or is it substantially different from other sections of the film? What sorts of transitions are used between shots? Why do the shots change at any given point (whether through editing to another shot or moving the camera without cutting) instead of at some other point in time? What do the camerawork and editing contribute to the emotional impact of the scene?  To the organization of space?  Of time?  Of narrative causality?  Of character psychology?  Of audience identification?  Do certain shot compositions seem to recur throughout the film in ways that suggest a symbolic interpretation? (You will obviously not be able to address all of these questions in such a short paper but you should consider which ones might be most relevant to your scene before preparing your analysis). Be sure to relate how the particular scene you analyze fits into the style, structure, and/or purpose of the overall film. BE SURE TO USE SPECIFIC EXAMPLES FROM THE FILM to support any statements you make!!

 

-You will need to see one of the following films—many are available at local video stores or the Grand Forks Public Library, but others may need to be special-ordered: 

The Birth of a Nation, Broken Blossoms, Victory (1919), Orphans of the Storm, The Cheat (1915), The Golden Chance, The Whispering Chorus, Battleship Potemkin, October, Sunrise, The Unknown, Hindle Wakes, Siren of the Tropics, The Passion of Joan of Arc (1928), Pandora’s Box, Man With The Movie Camera, Mystery of the Wax Museum (NOTE: on same DVD as its 1953 remake House of Wax), Doctor X, Footlight Parade, Dames, Flying Down to Rio, Rich and Strange, Number Seventeen, The Sin of Nora Moran, Cleopatra (1934), Kiss and Make-Up, Peter Ibbetson, Mad Love (1935), The General Died at Dawn, Young and Innocent, Scarlet Street, The Seventh Victim, Mildred Pierce, The Third Man, The Set-Up, His Kind of Woman, The Thing From Another World, Anchors Aweigh, The Band Wagon, The Seven Year Itch, Funny Face, Auntie Mame, Night of the Hunter, El Mariachi, Kiss or Kill, Natural Born Killers, Days of Heaven, Badlands, The Thin Red Line, Barry Lyndon, All That Jazz, The Ice Man Cometh, The Purple Rose of Cairo, Manhattan, Stardust Memories, Shadows and Fog, Crimes and Misdemeanors, Paper Moon, The Last Picture Show, Oliver Twist (1947 or 1922 versions only), Dr. Jekyll & Mr. Hyde (1920, 1931, or 1941 versions), The Mummy (1932 version only), The Stranger (1946), Othello (Orson Welles version), I Am Cuba, Zardoz, Don’t Look Now, What’s Up Doc, Persona, Dead Ringers, Audition, Dark City, Metropolis (restored Kino Video version only), L’Avventura, The Passenger, A Room With a View, Blood Simple, Schindler’s List, The Man Who Wasn’t There, Sleepy Hollow, Ghost World, Eraserhead, Mulholland Drive, U-Turn, Pleasantville, The Mission, Excalibur, King Arthur (2004 director’s cut), Burnt By the Sun, Dead Man, Novocaine, Napoleon Dynamite, Far From Heaven, Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow, Open Water, Sin City, Poseidon, King Kong (2005 version only),Monster House, Star Wars Episode 3: Revenge of the Sith, August Rush, No Country for Old Men, Boundless, Looking for Lillian, Vengeance of the Sorceress, Miss Mystic, Dark Highways, Dangers from Within, Good Night and Good Luck, The Good German, Crash, Babel, The Nativity Story, Apocalypto, The Messengers, 300, The Reaping, Pathfinder, Redbelt,, Sweet Land, Volver, Curse of the Golden Flower, Enchanted, Juno, Inland Empire

 

 

OPTION 2) -- One ten-page (3000 to 4000-word) research paper

      (two alternative topics):
      Recommended only for more advanced and/or ambitious film students, especially English majors or History majors

   NOTE: To avoid a mid-term deficiency for having a missing paper mid-semester, you must submit a one-page status report of how your research and film-watching is coming along by February 26th.  Be sure to start locating and watching the necessary films and reading the necessary sources immediately.

 

WARNING:   Doing either of the ten-page paper options will require active research, including outside readings (in the library, not on-line) and film viewings, and will realistically take several weeks to complete. Some films may need to be special-ordered. You CAN NOT expect to put off starting this assignment until the week before it’s due! It is strongly recommended that you consult with your instructor before choosing this option.

 

Worth 80 points -- Due April 15th, 2008

OPTION 2A-Write a 10-page survey of the career of one of the following major directors. You will need to watch at least seven or eight feature films made by the director you choose, including at least one or two from his early career, one or two from his middle career, and one or two from his late career. Directors you may choose from include: D. W. Griffith, Cecil B. DeMille, Erich von Stroheim, Charles Chaplin, Frank Capra, John Ford, Howard Hawks, Orson Welles, Ingmar Bergman, François Truffaut, Michelangelo Antonioni, Akira Kurosawa, Sergei Eisenstein, Stanley Kubrick, Fritz Lang, Billy Wilder, or Ernst Lubitsch. (NOTE: with filmmakers like Chaplin and Griffith who made many short films as well as features, you may watch FOUR short films of 10-20 min. each instead of ONE feature, eight shorts instead of two features, etc.  Try not to pick every title at random, but look for as many titles as possible that seem to be representative of the director’s work at each period in his career. That way you will be better able to assess how any random titles you pick fit into that director’s style. Books and articles on the directors are likely to mention key titles that are typical of their work. Several of these directors have had multi-disc DVD sets devoted to various segments of their careers, but be aware that it may be difficult or impossible to find many titles by these filmmakers in Grand Forks video stores. ADDITIONAL NOTE: since a few of these directors also wrote or acted in other directors’ films, be sure to discuss only the films they actually directed)

WHAT TO WRITE: This paper should begin with a brief overview of the director (about one page), including discussion of some of the distinguishing trademarks in the director’s work (themes and subject material, recurring motifs, character types, visual style, editing style, levels of meaning, autobiographical content, etc.). Then write about one or two pages of discussion on each of the films you viewed, beginning with the oldest and progressing chronologically to the latest, explaining how each illustrates or departs from the director’s typical approach. Another way of organizing your paper would be to treat the director’s themes and techniques one at a time in the order of importance you feel they belong (and explaining why you rank them that way), giving examples from each of the films you saw before moving on to the next theme or technique. This approach may be more appropriate for directors who write their own scripts. It might also be worthwhile to explain how the director handles one or more of the specific filmmaking concepts covered in your textbook (using appropriate SPECIFIC EXAMPLES from the films). Your conclusion need only be about a page or so to present your personal evaluation of the director’s work, always using specific examples from the films to illustrate your points. Be sure to include specific examples from each film that support any assertions you make about it. Do NOT write a synopsis of any of the films! Describe instead the scenes that illustrate your points. NOTE: You must include an additional page citing the reference works that you consulted and the editions of the films you watched (identifying the video release companies & video release dates/versions, since some copies may vary in content or quality). Also note the warning below about relying on other sources. Check at least several different encyclopedia entries and if possible one or more of the biographical references they cite. Be aware that on-line references like the IMDB and especially Wikipedia are not always trustworthy sources for specific data, and are merely a useful starting point for basic information. Even comprehensive and fairly well-respected publications like the AFI Catalog and the CineBooks Motion Picture Guide contain obvious plot and cast/credit errors (some of them major mistakes) for a substantial number of entries, which you should make note of in your paper if you notice them.) They also describe films that no longer exist in any form and others that survive only in fragments. (In other words, you’d better BE SURE TO WATCH any films you describe!)

 

OPTION 2B-Write a 10-page survey of the scholarship on and critical reaction to one of the major films of cinema history listed below. (A few title choices include comparing the remake or revised re-issue.) You must first find and watch the film(s), make a few brief notes on your personal reactions, and then seek out and read at least TWO or more reviews written at the time it was first released PLUS three or more written over the years between that time and the present—the more, the better. (HINT: The Chester Fritz Library has hardbound books containing thousands of film reviews from Variety and The New York Times, a separate collection of all other New York Times articles ever published about films, as well as anthologies of various original and later reviews. The 12-volume CineBooks Motion Picture Guide has a brief and often highly opinionated appraisal of almost every sound feature film released in the United States and many silent films. The multi-volume Magill’s Survey of Cinema has critical commentaries on selected noteworthy films. These book collections are all in the main floor reference section. There are also in-depth studies of certain films in the regular film section books upstairs in the PN shelves with additional reviews, citations, and data. These make reviews much easier to find than tracking down the actual newspaper articles on microfilm. Sometimes original-era reviews can be found on line, but ON-LINE SOURCES ARE INADEQUATE for this sort of research and can often take much longer than looking up reviews and extracts from original sources conveniently collected in these books. Be aware that on-line references like the IMDB and especially Wikipedia are not always trustworthy sources for specific data, and are merely a useful starting point for basic information. Even comprehensive and fairly well-respected publications like the AFI Catalog and the CineBooks Motion Picture Guide contain obvious plot and cast/credit errors (some of them major) for a substantial number of entries, which you should make note of in your paper if you notice them.)

After that, look for later analyses and commentaries from a variety of sources, including film reference books, biographical books or articles about the director, collections of film criticism, books dealing with the genre the film falls into, etc. (A few directors and even select individual films actually have books devoted to them –for example, The Complete Films of Cecil B. DeMille, Focus on Chaplin, Focus on D. W. Griffith, Focus on The Birth of a Nation, etc.—that conveniently reprint a variety of reviews, quotes, and commentaries, both contemporary and more recent!) After reading several reactions, watch the film again two or three times, re-evaluate it, and start to formulate an understanding of the film’s overall critical reputation. If the DVD has an audio commentary track, be sure to watch it at least once with the commentary and explore any additional supplementary materials the disc includes, especially documentaries that have interviews with the filmmakers. If you choose a silent film that has more than one choice of musical accompaniment, watch it at least once with each soundtrack.

Your paper should begin with your own initial reaction to the film, for perhaps the first page. Do NOT write a synopsis of the plot! You may, however, refer to important plot elements in your evaluation of the film. Your next page or two should discuss contemporary reaction to the film when it first came out. The remainder of the paper should recount a substantial number of later opinions about the film over the years, and then a few present-day reactions, comparing and contrasting them with each other and with the film’s initial reception. If appropriate, perhaps also note any circumstances that might have affected certain viewers’ opinions. Your final page may summarize your own feelings about the film and your understanding of it, but should mainly discuss how it may (or may not) have changed or been influenced by multiple viewings and by reading other critical commentary. NOTE: Be sure to include one additional page listing the sources you consulted (i.e., the body of your paper should be 10 pages but you will have 11 pages to hand in).

Films to choose from include: The Cheat, The Birth of a Nation (but NOT the revised 1930 reissue), Intolerance, Broken Blossoms, The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari, Battleship Potemkin, Greed, The Gold Rush (1925 version and revised 1940 reissue), The Lost World (1925 version), The Phantom of the Opera (1925 version and 1930 revised reissue), Ben-Hur (1925 version), The Niebelungen (in two parts: Siegfried and Kriemhild’s Revenge), The General (1927), The Jazz Singer (1927 version), The King of Kings (1927 premiere version and 1929 shortened reissue), Sunrise, The Godless Girl, The Passion of Joan of Arc, Redskin, Pandora’s Box, The Broadway Melody (1929), Applause, In Old Arizona, All Quiet on the Western Front (1930 version), Hell’s Angels (1930), Dracula (1930 version), M, City Lights, Doctor Jekyll & Mr. Hyde (compare 1931 and 1941 versions, on same DVD, and if possible the two different 1920 version(s) as well) The Old Dark House (1932 version), Modern Times, Cavalcade, The Sin of Nora Moran, It Happened One Night, The Black Cat (1934 version), The Bride of Frankenstein, Grand Illusion, Only Angels Have Wings, Stagecoach (1939 version), Meet John Doe, The Grapes of Wrath, How Green Was My Valley, Double Indemnity, The Big Sleep (1946 version), The Ox-Bow Incident, Children of Paradise, D.O.A. (1950 version), Rashomon, All About Eve, Sunset Boulevard, On the Waterfront, The Ten Commandments (compare 1923 and 1956 versions), Vertigo, The Searchers, The Seventh Seal, Wild Strawberries, The Three Faces of Eve, The 400 Blows, Jules and Jim, Ben-Hur (compare 1926 and 1959 versions), The High and the Mighty, Last Year at Marienbad, L’Avventura, Lawrence of Arabia, The Seven Samurai, Yojimbo, Tom Jones, Persona, 2001: a space odyssey, Midnight Cowboy, Walkabout, The Conformist, The Passenger, Stardust Memories, Interiors, Crimes and Misdemeanors, Stroszek, Aguirre the Wrath of God, Bagdad Café, Bladerunner, Blue Velvet, Dead Ringers, Do the Right Thing.

 

 

 

OPTION 3) -- Write a screenplay and make a movie!
      Recommended for students especially interested in film production and who have both the time and energy to do it!

          You will need access to a camcorder and computer with video editing software (already having your own is preferable).

          NOTE: This option requires a certain amount of technical know-how, but mainly lots of time, as well as reliable collaborators to serve as cast, crew, and resources for locations and props. (See detailed notes below)

 

Screenplay worth 40 points - Due February 26th, 2008

-Write a short screenplay (from five to twenty pages) that incorporates the basic plot elements of exposition, development, crisis, climax, and resolution. USE STANDARD SCREENPLAY FORMATTING (see below). Limit yourself to no more than six characters, and settings that you might be able to find around Grand Forks or in your own home town. Include a cover page (500-word maximum) with a 100-word synopsis and a brief narrative analysis “pitching” the movie (200-400 words). A “storyboard” is not necessary, but you may find it useful during the production process. Your synopsis and analysis may be typed in 10 to 12-point Times Roman, Palatino, Garamond, or equivalent font with one-inch page margins, but for the script itself, be sure to use standard screenplay formatting (this must be 12-point Courier type with the conventional indents for scene description, character names, and dialogue). Download the screenplay template on line for a sample with the correct formatting built into a ready-made style menu you can use in Microsoft Word.

 

Completed movie worth 40 points - Due May 1st, 2008

-Produce and direct the movie from your screenplay using digital video equipment to shoot it and a computer to edit it. It should run somewhere between five and thirty minutes when finished. Photography and editing should demonstrate some of the concepts covered in class. A handout is available describing basic “no-budget” production techniques. Turn in the completed movie on a DVD (preferred format) or a VCD, a miniDV or Digital 8 tape, an S-VHS or regular VHS tape, or if it is short enough, possibly as an .avi, .mov, or .mpg file on a CD-ROM or DVD-ROM (please do not turn in a web-quality .wmv file or lo-res .mov file). Student movie projects will be shown in class on the day normally scheduled for final exams. You should also consider entering the annual Forx Film Fest at the Empire Arts Center, the Fargo Film Festival, or submitting your work to be included in one of the Empire’s occasional programs of independent movies or MSU-Moorhead’s weekly cable TV program “Underexposed.” For more details on this project, see below and talk with your instructor.

 

MORE on making a movie (see also below)

 


*IN LIEU OF THESE TERM PAPERS, and after consultation and instructor approval, a student may make a short movie (on video, running approximately 5-15 min.) demonstrating key concepts of narrative filmmaking covered in the class. A finished script of about 5-15 pages in standard screenplay form will be due the same time the first paper would be due, along with a brief narrative analysis of your proposed movie. (If you use Corel WordPerfect, Wordpad, MS-Works, or some other word processing software instead of Microsoft Word, you may wish to download the .rtf file of the unfinished screenplay exercise on line at this site,  or the simpler screenplay sample at this site which may work as a style template with your word processor’s pull-down style menu, and at least will show you the standard format style to follow. Simply delete the existing text and replace it with your own in the appropriate style for easy formatting.) The final project will be due by the week of the last test, turned in on either miniDV or Digital 8 tape, DVD, or as an mpeg file on a CD. You will need access to a camcorder and a personal computer with video editing software. A special handout on “no-budget moviemaking” is available for anyone interested, describing basic considerations and giving some tips and hints to make the process more efficient and your movie more effective. This project will definitely be a great deal more work than the two 5-page papers, and will most likely be more work than a 10-page research paper, but may prove more rewarding and more fun to do for students interested in pursuing a filmmaking career.

It is most feasible to make a movie if you already have and are at least somewhat familiar with a digital camcorder (either miniDV or Digital 8) and some sort of NLE computer software (such as Avid, Adobe Premiere Pro or Premiere Elements, Final Cut Pro or Final Cut Express, iMovie, Vegas Video, Pinnacle, Roxio, Windows Movie Maker, etc.). Camcorders that record video to DVD, hard drives, or memory cards as mpeg files require their own specialized editing software and are not recommended for anything other than simple home movies. (While the initial image may look acceptable, picture quality can decrease substantially during the editing process due to mpeg file decompression and recompression.) HDV camcorders can produce impressively sharp original pictures, but also can pose major problems when trying to edit the footage on typical home computers, and even more problems re-encoding it to a standard-resolution final copy that can be played by others. You should know in advance that camcorders using VHS, 8mm, or Hi8 tape require special digital conversion hardware for editing on computer. However, it is still possible to make do with an older analog camcorder if your computer video card has the proper connections and can digitize the analog signal. (You can even use real film if you have lots of money to spend). Note that editing with a laptop or a low-end computer may require you to use a much lower-resolution image than you actually shot in order to see the action in real time without jerkiness. This will look acceptable only in very small images like those used on the web or ipods. Try to edit at full-quality if at all possible, or your final DVD will be disappointing.

HINT: estimate that it will take approximately an hour to shoot each minute of final running time, plus an additional hour or two to edit each screen minute. For a short movie, this translates into planning a full day or weekend for shooting, and another one for editing, but scheduling difficulties may easily spread that over several days or weeks. The advance planning itself (lining up actors, locations, and props) may be double or triple that time commitment, or even more. In order to complete this type of project within one semester, it’s a good idea to write your screenplay with locations and actors already in mind, and start production early if you wish to use this option. As a producer, your preproduction and production process (arranging for everything to happen) can become extremely time-consuming if actors, props, or locations are difficult to obtain or fall through at the last minute. While not a requirement, your script will be much easier to shoot if you limit your story to between two and six main characters, set it in the present day rather than the past or the future, and use only one to three simple main locations besides any brief establishing or transition shots (e.g., landscapes, cityscapes, building exteriors, cars driving, etc.).

If you do decide to make a movie, the UND English Department does have two computers dedicated to digital video editing (usable with DV or HDV signals but NO analog capture capability). It would be a good idea to bring your own external firewire hard drive if you can’t finish your project in one session, and simply for backup of your files. Some other university departments may also have computer video editing workstations available.  ANOTHER NOTE: If you don’t have a DVD burner, a blank CD-R can hold approximately 2-3 min. of “raw” .avi or Final Cut digital .mov video files (with either separate .wav or .aiff audio files or composite audio), whether this video has already been edited on the computer or simply captured from a camcorder. The same CD-R could hold about 10-15 min. of DVD-quality video that has been encoded to an mpeg-2 file (which will play on a computer and a few DVD players), or close to an hour using a more highly compressed VCD-compliant mpg file (which will play on a number of DVD players). A blank DVD-R that can hold two hours worth of mpeg-2 encoded video will hold only about 20 minutes of DV-quality .avi or .mov files (which take up about 15 GB per hour). If you have your own computer, it’s a good idea to have a separate 80-100 Gb or larger hard drive dedicated solely to storing your movie files while editing. BACK UP YOUR FILES OFTEN!! Both PCs and Macs can freeze or shut down your editing software without warning, causing you to lose all the work you’ve done since your last save! SAVE YOUR PROJECT FILE OFTEN and keep an extra updated copy on a USB flash drive after each editing session!!  It is strongly recommended that when your final cut is completed you export the entire movie back to DV tape as the least expensive and most reliable backup, before encoding it for DVD. A one-hour miniDV or Digital 8 tape (costing $3 or $4) holds about 15GB worth of full DV-quality audio-video data, along with metadata like timecode, time of day, date, and exposure information.

Try to use software and hardware that will let you edit with full DV quality. If at all possible, avoid using the very highly compressed web-quality .wmv, .mov, .rm, .ram, or .mpg files with lower resolution and/or frame capture rates (even though those may be faster to edit and/or output). A low-powered computer may not be able to display the DV standard image (720x480 pixels at 30 frames per second) with smooth motion or sharp resolution, and certain software may force you to capture it at a lower quality in order to play back and edit. On many computers Windows Movie Maker usually defaults to low-resolution and must be manually set to capture at DV quality. Using an external firewire hard drive can help a lower-powered computer handle large video files. If you capture and edit at DV quality, Windows Movie Maker can then export your finished movie back to your camcorder at DV quality or save it to disk as a DV-quality .avi file, but it does not have DVD encoding capability. The .avi file for a movie of about 10-15 minutes or less can still be copied to one blank DVD. A longer movie will need to be broken up into smaller segments of up to 4 GB per .avi file (unless you have mpeg encoding software or have a standalone DVD recorder that will let you play back your DV tape through a firewire input). If you have an older hard drive or an external drive formatted for FAT32 (which is the only system that can be used interchangeably by both PCs and Macs) then your maximum file size is limited to 2 GB, which is only about 8 or 9 minutes. Note that even with a faster computer, encoding your finished movie to a DVD-quality mpeg file may take five to ten times longer than its total running time, possibly even longer if you are editing HDV. In this case, it may be easiest to output the finished movie back to digital tape through the firewire cable to your camcorder, or to analog tape using your computer’s A/V outputs, and make a copy of that to hand in. Note also that for various technical reasons, consumer-model camcorders that record directly on DVDs or memory cards instead of tape are not recommended for video production. (Still another note: If none of this makes any sense, you should probably consider one of the term paper options!  If some of it makes sense, check to see what equipment you already have and ask about the rest!)

MORE on making a movie

BACK to home page